WHY GERMANY IS STILL THE TOUGHEST GROCERY MARKET IN THE WORLD
Show notes
Companion Brief for this trilogy: insights.wfr-advisory.com Connect with Jan Wapelhorst on LinkedIn for weekly insights on German retail. Website: wfr-advisory.com Email: info@wfr-advisory.com
Show transcript
00:00:00: Welcome back to Decoding German Retail, part two of the season-two finale trilogy.
00:00:30: I get this conversation about twice a month.
00:00:34: An international brand director sits across from me and says something like, we have successfully entered France Italy the UK And Poland.
00:00:45: Germany should be next.
00:00:47: It looks similar in size.
00:00:49: Well it's bit bigger though.
00:00:51: Similar structure Same playbook Adapted for local taste And I nod politely because I do not want to crush the moment.
00:01:04: Then, i ask one question How does your team currently handle that fact that Aldi and Lidl combined hold more grocery share than the top three UK retailers?
00:01:17: That's usually a pause followed by.
00:01:20: is THAT actually true?
00:01:22: It IS!
00:01:23: And it was about sick things in Germany that make it structurally different from every other major European grocery market.
00:01:32: This episode is for anyone who's planning a German Market Entry, A German Expansion or a German Pricing Strategy and wants to know why the successful Playbook From Other European Markets keeps breaking here.
00:01:50: six structural reasons.
00:01:52: if you leave with just one of the six clearly in your head.
00:01:57: You will walk into our next German conversation with a different set of expectations.
00:02:03: Reason one, four groups-one rulebook.
00:02:07: The german grocery market is controlled by four retail Groups that between them hold roughly eighty five percent for total market Edeka Raver Schwarzgruppe which is Liedl and Kauffland And Aldi Zürich and Aldinot.
00:02:24: Four buyers four sets of central conditions for negotiation calendars.
00:02:31: Compare this to France, for example where the top-four retailers hold about seventy five percent.
00:02:39: compare it to the UK Where The Top Four holds About sixty five percent and where at least you have a variety of formats in positioning strategies.
00:02:50: In Germany though if You want national coverage?
00:02:53: You negotiate with all four.
00:02:55: There's no meaningful alternative.
00:02:58: Regional supermarket chains exist, but they are shrinking.
00:03:01: Teghurt was absorbed.
00:03:03: Finneberg is under restructuring and goes into the river group.
00:03:07: The trend is towards more concentration not less.
00:03:12: This concentration means each of four has enormous structural leverage over any single supplier.
00:03:21: Losing one Group is losing about twenty percent of a national market.
00:03:27: Losing two is losing the ability to build real German business at all.
00:03:34: Reason Two Private label isn't a backup, it's the anchor.
00:03:40: In most European markets private labels place as supporting role The main brand's anchor on shelf?
00:03:47: The private label sits alongside as value option for price sensitive shoppers in Germany.
00:03:54: that logic inverted.
00:03:56: Private labor share in the German grocery market crossed a forty percent line several years ago and it continues to climb, so its more upto fifty now In hard discount is over ninety percent!
00:04:08: In full-range supermarkets well past forty.
00:04:12: In specific categories dairy basic bakery certain frozen segments tissue paper it's over sixty which means for the buyer private label isn't a hatch against branded suppliers.
00:04:25: Private label is the primary product line and branded supplies occupy their defensive positions around the retailer's own products.
00:04:34: This is a completely different mental model from what you find in France or the UK, though I have to admit especially Spain or The Netherlands.
00:04:43: private label has risen and is now very close toward.
00:04:47: we have a situation like Germany.
00:04:49: In Germany When you negotiate as a branded supplier, You're not negotiating with someone who sees you As partner.
00:04:57: You are negotiating With Someone Who Sees You As Competition To Their Own Product Line And Who Has Spent The Last Decade Systematically Improving That Product Line to Make It Less Dependant On Your Brand.
00:05:11: If your value proposition is Not Clearly and Ahead Of the retailer's own profit label In way that a shopper can perceive You will lose facings every year.
00:05:22: Slowly, if you're lucky Quickly.
00:05:25: If not Reason three Promotion is NOT a tool anymore It's a trap.
00:05:34: Think about it.
00:05:35: Over the last decade branded suppliers in Germany have tried to defend base pricing by expanding promotional death and promotion frequency.
00:05:44: The theory was simple Keep the sticker price high Win the volume on promotion.
00:05:51: The consumer still perceives the brand as premium.
00:05:55: It did not work.
00:05:57: What happened instead is that the German shopper learned That certain brands are only worth buying on promotion.
00:06:04: Learned to wait for next promotion a week Learned shopping baskets around promotional items.
00:06:13: The result is a promotional dependency that suppliers who cannot exit without volume collapse and the retailers have started to exploit systematically.
00:06:23: If you've entered German promotion escalation, your average selling price now considerably lower than your official pricelist – your buyer knows this!
00:06:33: Your buyer has data and your buyer will use it in every future negotiation.
00:06:39: your base price, which is a very hard argument to answer once it lands on the table.
00:06:49: Reason four The consumers stop trading up in many European markets.
00:06:55: Brand strategy assumes long-term trend towards premization.
00:07:00: Shoppers earn more, shoppers trade out brands right away.
00:07:04: In Germany over the last Three years, that assumption has broken.
00:07:08: Real disposable income has been under pressure.
00:07:13: Consumer sentiment surveys consistently show caution or pessimism.
00:07:20: Basket sizes have declined.
00:07:22: Premium item purchases per basket have declined and the shift is not cyclical.
00:07:27: It has structural drivers that will not simply reverse when the economy improves.
00:07:33: The consequence for branded suppliers is, That traditional growth pathway capture more shoppers get each shopper to spend more per visit to minimize the mix.
00:07:45: it's Not functioning in a way they did In twenty eighteen.
00:07:48: buyers see this as category data.
00:07:51: They know Pushing you for lower prices is not going to reduce demand because the demand Is already flattening from the shopper side which gives them structural leverage that did Not exist three years ago.
00:08:10: Reason five.
00:08:11: The buyer knows your cost structure better than You probably realize.
00:08:16: German buyers have been running cost benchmarking exercises For two decades now.
00:08:22: They have visibility into commodity prices, packaging costs, logistics rates labor cost indices, energy costs across your entire supply chain.
00:08:32: And they know what you're input costs should be doing this year based on public market data that anyone with a Bloomberg terminal can pull and they Know what your margin structure looks like based on your publicly disclosed financials or for private companies based on industry benchmarks they have compiled over years.
00:08:53: Which means when you walk into a meeting and ask for price increase, citing rising input costs Your buyer already has a counter analysis prepared on their side of the table.
00:09:05: If you request align with that data You may get some or all it.
00:09:10: if does not align exceeds what their data suggests you actually need, You will get a polite and very well-informed pushback.
00:09:20: The days of walking in with the general statement about inflation And expecting sympathy are over structured argumentation With your own transparencies.
00:09:31: now the price of admission to any serious price conversation In the German market.
00:09:37: Reason six Silence is the highest priced question.
00:09:44: This is a reason I have saved for last, because it's the one that most international suppliers misread demos consistently.
00:09:53: German negotiation culture treats silence as information not discomfort.
00:09:59: When a german buyer receives a proposal and pauses for eight to ten seconds before responding they are confused.
00:10:06: They're not building emotional pressure.
00:10:09: The eight seconds of silence is the moment when their way, whether your proposal fits what they had already decided to accept.
00:10:18: If the international supplier does not understand this They typically fill in the silence.
00:10:25: Of course we can be flexible on that particular point.
00:10:30: There may be some room for adjustment But if you increase the promotions each of those sentences gives away margin in exchange for filling silence that the buyer was not uncomfortable with.
00:10:44: The German buyer interprets this feeling behavior as a weakness of preparation, and every future negotiation will factor that weakness into
00:10:52: it.".
00:10:53: If you take one behavioral change to your next German meeting then it would be this – match the silence!
00:11:02: Can we do that?
00:11:09: Or twelve.
00:11:19: The first person who filled silence in a German negotiation almost ends up giving away something they did not need to give away and most of the time that person is NOT... ...the German buyer.
00:11:32: Six reasons Germany stays at toughest grocery market on the world.
00:11:37: Four groups with one rulebook Private label as the anchor, not the backup.
00:11:43: Promotion has a trap which cannot exist A consumer whose stopped trading up A buyer who knows your cost structure.
00:11:50: and a negotiation culture where silence has a price tag.
00:11:55: None of these six are new, none of them are secret but they compound!
00:12:00: The reason Germany feels harder than France or the UK is not that anything around this unique.
00:12:07: It's all six operate simultaneously in the same negotiations across all four of you possible counterparties elsewhere assumes you're dealing with one or two of these dynamics.
00:12:21: The German playbook has to address all six, or it fails at whichever one you underestimate which is why the international market entry stories that succeed here share a common pattern.
00:12:34: they took two or three years to build.
00:12:36: They involved deep local hires and the treaty germ retail as its own discipline not as an aberration on European retail.
00:12:46: Next week, the third and final episode of season two trilogy.
00:12:52: Ten things I wish someone had told me in sixteen years on the German buying side A seasonal finale And a piece that ties everything together.
00:13:03: Thank you for listening.
00:13:05: If this episode was useful You want to go deeper on the german retail landscape?
00:13:11: I've put together short companion briefs That pulls the whole picture together in one document, you can find it at insights.wfr-advisory.com.
00:13:21: The link is now on the show notes.
00:13:24: It's free!
00:13:24: You just ask for your email.
00:13:26: You can find everything on the website wfr-avisory.
00:13:31: com.
00:13:32: Thank you for listening today.
New comment